Skip to main content
Share:
When a co-founder leaves your startup: what to do

When a co-founder leaves your startup: what to do

Co-founder leaving your startup? What to do in the first week, and what the leaver keeps in Ireland, the UK and the US when there is no vesting.

12 min read

Your co-founder has told you they want out. Maybe it's a job offer, a baby on the way, or they've stopped believing in the idea. Either way, you're the one who stays, and you're now wondering what happens to their shares, their work and the company.

This page covers what to do when a co-founder is leaving your startup by choice. It starts with the first week, then explains what the law gives the leaver in Ireland, the UK and the US when you never set up vesting or an agreement, which is where many founders are when this happens. If your co-founder isn't leaving and you think they should, how to remove a co-founder covers that case instead.

Co-founder leaving the startup: what to do in the first week

If a co-founder is leaving and you have no vesting and no agreement, my advice for the first week is three things:

  1. Write down who owns what today.
  2. See a lawyer before you sign anything.
  3. Agree in writing what the one leaving keeps.

If you never set up a company at all, there's nothing on paper, so the risk is low. I'd still do all three.

Who owns what today means the shares and who holds them, who is a director, who can sign for the bank account, and whose name is on the domain, the code repository, the app store account and the social media accounts. Add any money owed either way: a loan one of you made, expenses never paid back. It takes an hour, and it stops the conversation from starting with two different memories.

A lawyer before you sign means a lawyer in the country where the company is set up, who reads what exists and tells you what it means. Not after you have shaken hands on a number. If shares are going to change hands, bring in an accountant too, because a transfer of shares can have tax consequences for either of you.

What the leaver keeps covers shares, money, any ongoing role and the work they made. Put all of it in one signed document. Otherwise, a year from now, you'll each remember a different deal.

First, work out which situation you're in

What the leaver walks away with depends almost entirely on what you set up before. There are three common starting points.

Your situationWhat it usually means
You never incorporated a companyNo shares exist. The risk is low, but check who owns the work, and whether you were already trading together.
You incorporated and issued shares, with no vesting and no agreementThe leaver usually keeps all their shares. Anything else has to be negotiated.
You have vesting and a signed agreementWhat you signed decides. Read it with a lawyer.

If you never incorporated

Incorporating a company means signing legal documents and issuing shares. If you never did, there are no shares to argue about, and the leaving co-founder has nothing on paper to point to. This is the easy case.

Two things are still worth checking.

The work they made. In all three countries, copyright in code, designs and writing belongs first to the person who made it, unless they made it as an employee in the course of their job, and handing it over only works in writing, signed by them. That's the rule in Ireland's Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000 (sections 23 and 120), the UK's Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (sections 11 and 90), and in the US, sections 201 and 204 of the Copyright Act. In the US, section 201 adds that the authors of a joint work co-own it. So if your leaving co-founder wrote the first version of the product, they own that code (or, if you wrote it together, share it) until they sign it over, to you or to the company once you set one up. Get that signature now, while you're on good terms. Intellectual property for startups covers why it matters later, when investors check.

Whether you were already trading together. If the two of you were selling and sharing the money before any company existed, the law may treat you as partners even though you never signed anything. In Ireland and the UK, the Partnership Act 1890 (Irish text, UK text) defines a partnership as people "carrying on a business in common with a view of profit". In the US it depends on the state; Delaware's partnership law, for example, says a partnership forms whether or not the people intend it. If this applies to you, ask a lawyer how to end it cleanly.

If you incorporated and issued shares, with no vesting

This is the hard case. When co-founders set up a company, get their shares and never put vesting or leaver terms in place, the shares are simply theirs. Leaving the company doesn't change that.

So if your co-founder holds half the company today, they can walk away with half the company. That's the default. Anything better for you has to be agreed with them.

There are three usual ways it can go:

  • They keep everything. Sometimes fair, if they worked for years and leave on good terms. But a big stake held by someone who no longer works on the company can make investors wary, and you'll be doing all the work for a smaller share.
  • They keep part and pass the rest to the founders who stay. This is often the cleanest outcome. A lawyer drafts the transfer, and an accountant checks the tax on it before anyone signs.
  • The company buys their shares back. This needs money, and the law limits it. In Ireland (section 105 of the Companies Act 2014) and the UK (section 692 of the Companies Act 2006), a company generally has to pay for its own shares out of profits it has made or out of money raised by issuing new shares. A UK private company can also use its capital, but only through a formal procedure in the Act. In Delaware, section 160 generally bars a buyback that would impair the company's capital. Most early startups have neither the profits nor the cash, so ask a lawyer before you plan around this one.

A fair place to start the conversation: what they would have kept if you had set up vesting at the start. The founder vesting guide shows how a schedule works. It isn't binding, because you never signed it, but it gives you both a number that isn't just your opinion against theirs. If the talk turns into an argument, how to resolve a co-founder dispute goes through it step by step.

If you have vesting and a signed agreement

Then most of the answer is already written down. Read the vesting terms and the leaver clauses in your co-founder agreement, or your shareholders' agreement if you have one, with a lawyer. Usually the leaver keeps the part that has vested and the company can take back or buy back the rest, often at a low price, but your exact wording decides.

If you feel generous and want to let them keep more than the agreement gives them, be careful. Extra shares for the leaver come out of everyone else's stake, and if you have investors, what you signed with them may require their consent for changes to the shares.

Make the departure official

Whichever case you're in, close the loose ends properly:

  • Their role as a director. They resign in writing, and the company files it. In Ireland, you tell the Companies Registration Office on Form B10 within 14 days (section 149 of the Companies Act 2014). In the UK, you tell Companies House about director changes within 14 days. In the US the paperwork depends on the state, so ask your lawyer.
  • The shares. Any transfer gets a signed transfer form and an update to the company's register of shareholders. Update your cap table the same day.
  • The work. If they never signed their work over to the company, have them do it now, in writing (see the copyright rules above).
  • Their job. If they're on the payroll, their employment ends too. Ask your accountant to handle the final pay, and a lawyer if they have an employment contract.
  • Access. Remove them as a signatory on the bank account, then change passwords and move every account in their name to the company.
  • A non-compete. Don't count on one. Whether it holds depends on the country and the wording, so ask a lawyer before you rely on it.

Hand over the work, and tell people yourself

Agree a handover period before they go: a few weeks is often enough for a co-founder to walk you through their customers, suppliers, code and passwords. Write it down as they go.

Then decide who owns their area from now on. If you split co-founder roles and responsibilities by area, their area needs a new owner, even if that's you for now. If the company is past its first hires, the founder to CEO transition helps you move your own time around the gap.

Tell people in this order: the team first, then your investors and your most important customers, then everyone else. Do the investor and customer calls yourself, before they hear it secondhand. Agree the wording with your co-founder, so you both tell the same story. Some leavers are happy to stay on as an advisor for a while; ask, since it makes the story easier to tell.

A made-up example: the camping gear marketplace

Imagine two founders, Sara and Kofi, nine months into a marketplace where people rent out their camping gear. The founders, the business and the numbers are all made up. They incorporated in month two and took half the shares each. They never set up vesting or signed an agreement. Kofi built the booking site. Then he gets a job offer he can't turn down and tells Sara he's leaving at the end of the month.

On paper, Kofi keeps 50% of the company. Sara will run it alone, and she plans to raise money within a year.

Sara starts with the three steps. She lists who owns what: 50% each, both directors, the domain and the code repository in Kofi's name. She books a lawyer before saying anything about numbers. Then she opens the conversation with the vesting they never set up. Under a four-year schedule with a one-year cliff, Kofi would leave with nothing, and to him that feels unfair after nine months of building the product.

They settle in the middle. Kofi keeps 10%. He transfers the other 40% to Sara for a nominal price, signs the code he wrote over to the company, moves the domain and the repository, and resigns as a director. He gives two hours a week for the first month to answer questions. Sara's lawyer drafts one document covering all of it, an accountant checks the tax on the transfer, and they both sign before Kofi's last day.

If you're the one leaving

The same steps apply from your side. Tell your co-founder early and in private, before you tell anyone else. Offer a handover period and mean it. Expect the question about your shares, and think about what's fair to the people who carry on. Get your own lawyer to read anything before you sign it. And sign over the work you did for the company: you'd want that from them if the roles were reversed.

After they've gone

The legal side gets most of the attention, but the hardest part is often being alone. You lose the person you tested every idea on, and every decision feels heavier with nobody to share it.

Don't rush to replace them. A new co-founder picked in a hurry to fill a gap is a risky choice, and if you do look, how to find a co-founder covers where and how to choose. In the meantime, find a few other founders to talk to every couple of weeks. Where to find a founder community covers where to look.

Then fix what made this hard. If there are still two or more founders, put vesting and a signed agreement in place for the ones who stay, drafted by a lawyer where the company is set up. In the US, adding vesting to shares can raise a tax question (the section 83(b) election, which has a 30-day deadline when it applies). Whether it applies depends on how the vesting is set up, so talk to an accountant or tax lawyer before the vesting starts. The next time a co-founder leaves, the answer will already be on paper.

Continue Reading

Join 700+ founders who got personalized advice

Ready to Move Faster?

Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.

No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.