Skip to main content
Share:
Why co-founders fall out: six causes, and what to do

Why co-founders fall out: six causes, and what to do

Why co-founders fall out: equity, roles, who decides, money, working hours and direction. A made-up example of each, and what to do about it.

7 min read

Co-founders rarely fall out over one bad week. The break usually traces back to something they never settled at the start, which got harder to settle the longer they left it. Here are six causes that explain why co-founders fall out: the equity split, unclear roles, who decides, money and salaries, working hours, and strategy. They come in no particular order.

Many of them start as an unspoken assumption about equity, fundraising, how the money is used, or time and sacrifice: the hours each of you gives and what you are each ready to give up for the startup to work.

Why co-founders fall out: six causes

To make each cause concrete, here is one made-up startup that runs into all six. Picture two founders, Rosa and Idris, both invented, who start a service that sends a mechanic to fix bikes at people's homes and offices. Their numbers are invented too.

The equity split

Talking about shares feels awkward when the company is two people and an idea, so founders put it off. It only gets harder once the company looks worth something, because by then each of you has a good reason to deserve more: the idea, the code, the first customers.

Rosa and Idris never discuss it. A year in, they have 300 regular customers, and an investor asks how the shares are split. Rosa says the idea was hers. Idris says he built the booking app and hired every mechanic. Each argument sounds fair to the person making it.

Start from an equal split, and move away from it only for a clear difference: one of you full-time and the other not, one bringing the idea plus months of work, or one putting in money. Always add vesting, so a founder who leaves early doesn't keep a full share. How to split equity between co-founders goes through the split, and how founder vesting works covers the vesting. Write down what you agree now, even before you set up the company. A note between the two of you is not a shareholders' agreement, though, so once the company exists, have a lawyer in the country where it is set up turn the note into a signed co-founder agreement.

Unclear roles

At the start everyone does a bit of everything, and that's fine. The trouble comes when nobody owns anything. Jobs fall between you, two people claim the same win, and once you hire, staff get one instruction from one founder and the opposite from the other.

Rosa and Idris both manage the mechanics. Rosa tells them to take weekend jobs, and Idris tells them weekends are off. The mechanics soon learn to ask whichever founder will say yes.

You don't need detailed job descriptions to fix this. From day one, agree who has the final say in each area: product, sales and money, plus any area where decisions come up every week, like Rosa and Idris's mechanics. The day-to-day work can stay shared until your first hires. Co-founder roles and responsibilities shows how to pick an owner for each area and fit it all on one page.

Who decides

Owners settle most decisions. A few are too big for one owner: the direction of the company, whether to raise money and on what terms, bringing in another co-founder, and selling the company. Those belong to all of you, and with two founders and no way to break a tie, a disagreement on one of them can run for months.

Idris wants to make their best mechanic a third co-founder. Rosa doesn't. They make that decision together, and they never agreed what happens when they can't, so it goes round in circles for weeks while the mechanic starts looking for another job.

Agree how you break a tie now, while you're getting on. With three or more founders, that can be a vote. With two, name a third person you both trust before any of these decisions comes up, and go with their view. If you're stuck on one already, how to resolve a co-founder dispute starts by working out whose decision it is.

Money and salaries

Money fights come in a few kinds. You disagree on what to spend on first. One of you needs an income now and the other can wait. Even expense claims cause friction, small as they are, when nobody agreed what counts as a company cost.

Rosa has savings to live on for a year. Idris has rent to pay and needs a salary within four months. When the first €20,000 of revenue is in the bank, Idris wants a small salary for both of them, and Rosa wants a second van. They have also never agreed whether the tools each of them buys for the van count as a company cost, and the receipts are piling up.

Before any money arrives, say how much each of you needs to live on, and from when. Agree what the first money goes on, and a simple rule for expenses. Who pays for what between co-founders covers salaries, the money you put in yourselves, and the rest of that conversation.

Working hours and commitment

Effort is easy to promise and hard to compare. The one working weekends starts to read the other's free evenings as a lack of commitment. Then life changes, with a child, say, or an illness in the family. One founder has less time to give, and if nobody talks about it, the founder who carries on can feel betrayed.

In year two Rosa has a baby and moves to four days a week. She told Idris about the baby months ago. She never mentioned the four days, and he finds out a week before they start. To him it feels like she has stepped back from the company.

Say early how many hours each of you will give, whether either of you keeps a job for now, and what you're each ready to give up for the startup. Agree, too, what happens when life changes, before it does. Co-founder expectations covers that talk and the monthly check-in that keeps it up to date.

Strategy and direction

At the start you agree on the idea, so you assume you agree on the company. Then real choices arrive: who to sell to, how fast to grow, whether to raise. What customers tell you can often be read two ways, and each of you reads it your own way.

After 18 months, offices with staff bikes bring in most of Rosa and Idris's revenue. Idris wants to drop home visits and sell only to companies. Rosa started the business to fix bikes for people at home and wants to keep both. They argue about the roadmap. Underneath, they picture different companies.

Find the layer you actually disagree on: the mission, the market, the timeline, or this quarter's plan. Then each of you writes your three-year picture alone, and you compare them. When co-founders disagree on direction walks through it. Direction is one of the decisions you make together, so the tie rule from "Who decides" applies here too.

Settle the six before they start

All six are cheaper to sort out before they turn into a fight, while nothing is riding on the answer. If you haven't committed to a co-founder yet, the questions to ask a potential co-founder cover most of them. If you already have, block out an hour this month and go through the list together: equity, roles, who decides, money, time and direction. Write down what you agree, and date it.

When it has gone too far

Sometimes settling the cause isn't enough. You want different companies, or one of you no longer wants to do the work. If you both see it, when a co-founder leaves covers how to part with the company and the relationship intact.

If one of you is clearly not delivering, my advice is: don't let it pass. Sit down and find out what is going on. How to remove a co-founder covers that conversation, and what comes after it if nothing changes.

Continue Reading

Join 700+ founders who got personalized advice

Ready to Move Faster?

Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.

No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.