Skip to main content
Share:
When a co-founder puts in more money than the other

When a co-founder puts in more money than the other

Loan, shares or expense? What to do when one co-founder puts in more money, how to split costs before funding, zero out what's owed and set salaries.

14 min read

Before there is any outside money, the founders pay for everything: the company registration, the first laptops, the stock, the van repair nobody planned for. Sooner or later you get a co-founder putting in more money than the other, and nobody says what that money is. Is it a loan, or does it buy more of the company?

Whichever it is, write it down from day one.

The short version

  • Write it down from day one. Every amount, who paid it, and what it is.
  • Ideally, everyone puts in the same money from the start. If co-founder A puts in 100, B puts in 100 and C puts in 100, you are square, and there is nothing to settle later. When a cost comes up after that, split it equally.
  • When one of you puts in more, treat it by default as a loan to the company, paid back first.
  • Extra shares only if you all agree, at a price you set in writing.
  • Agree when you zero out. Your co-founder agreement says who puts the money in, and when you settle up so no founder is ahead of another.

Who pays for what before funding

Start with the same amount each

Work out what the first months will cost, then each founder puts in the same share of it. Startup financial projections, with a worked example shows how to build that list month by month. With equal money from the start, nobody is ahead, so the only thing to track between you is what comes after.

Split later costs equally

When a cost comes up that the company can't cover, split it equally between the founders and pay it into the company. That includes the surprises: the broken equipment, the legal letter, the order you can only take if you buy stock this week.

Avoid dividing costs by category, where one founder pays for software from their own pocket and another pays for ads. It sounds fair, but after a few months it gets hard to say who has paid more, and the company's own books show none of it.

Before the company exists

Until you incorporate, there is no company to lend to or to pay you back. Whoever pays keeps the receipt and adds it to a shared list with the date and what it was for. Once the company exists, your agreement says which of those costs the company takes on.

Keep the money visible

  • Open a business bank account as soon as the company exists, and run every company cost through it.
  • Keep one shared sheet of money going in and out: date, amount, which founder, and what it is (equal share, loan or expense to reimburse). Every founder can see it.
  • Set a spending limit. The founder who owns the money area can spend up to an agreed amount alone. Above it, everyone agrees first. Look at the sheet together once a month. Co-founder roles and responsibilities shows how to give each area an owner and write down a limit like this one.

A co-founder putting in more money than the other: loan, shares or expense

Money one founder puts in beyond their equal share can take three forms. Name the form when the money goes in.

Expense to reimburseLoan to the companyShares
What it isYou paid a company cost yourselfYou lend the company moneyYou buy more of the company
Do you get it back?Yes, the amount on the receiptYes, in full, on the terms you wrote downNo. You own more instead
Does the equity split change?NoNoYes
What to write downReceipt, date, what it was forAmount, date, any interest, when and in what order it is repaidPrice per share, number of shares, everyone's agreement

By default, a loan, paid back first

A loan keeps money and ownership apart. The founder who lent gets their money back, and the equity split stays what you agreed for the work ahead. That matters because the split should be about future work. How to split equity between co-founders starts from equal, and money is one of the few clear reasons to move away from it, in small steps.

Write down how the loan comes back: when (on a date, or when the company reaches a point you name), whether it carries interest, and that it is repaid first, before any other money goes back to the founders. In the countries below, a loan from a founder also shows up in the company's records, so your accountant will need the same details anyway.

Extra shares, only at a price you all agree in writing

Sometimes a founder wants shares for their money instead. That is fine if every founder agrees, and if you set the price in writing. The price is the hard part, because a young company has no obvious value. Set it too low and a modest amount of cash buys a big piece of the company. The worked example below shows how much the price changes the result. Issuing new shares is also a legal step, so a lawyer should do it. Tax can follow too, and the founder vesting guide covers the tax points to check in each country when founders get shares, and why a founder who puts in money still vests on the same terms.

A worked example: three founders and the zero-out

This example is made up, and so is every number in it. Maeve, Tomasz and Dario start a company in Ireland that rents wetsuits to surf schools and cleans them between sessions. They incorporate in month 1 and split the equity equally, all three on vesting. Their agreement says each founder puts in €6,000, later costs are split equally, and anything one founder pays beyond that is a loan or an expense to reimburse. Spending over €500 needs all three to agree. They zero out when the company raises outside money or has six months of costs in the bank, whichever comes first.

Here is their sheet for the first nine months:

MonthWhat happenedMaeveTomaszDarioWhat it is
1Starting money€6,000€6,000€6,000Equal share
1Registration and website, paid before the bank account opened€400Expense to reimburse
3Drying racks, bought on his own card after all three agreed€1,150Expense to reimburse
480 extra wetsuits for a summer order. Only Tomasz has the cash€12,000Loan, paid back first, no interest
7Van repair, split equally€300€300€300Equal share
The company owes each founder€6,700€18,300€7,450

In month 10 they raise money from two angel investors. They told both investors about the loan and the receipts before they invested, since the loan is in the accounts anyway, and the investors agreed that part of the round would repay it. The agreement now kicks in:

MaeveTomaszDario
Owed before the zero-out€6,700€18,300€7,450
Paid back first: the loan and the receipts€400€12,000€1,150
Still owed after the zero-out€6,300€6,300€6,300

After the zero-out, every founder is owed the same €6,300, the equal money they all put in. Between the three of them, nobody is ahead. They leave it in the company and agree to repay it to all three at once, when the company can afford it. Tomasz got his €12,000 back, and the equity is still equal.

The same money as shares

Now say Tomasz had wanted shares for his €12,000, and Maeve and Dario agreed. They have to set a price, which means agreeing what the company is worth before his money goes in.

Value agreed before Tomasz's €12,000Tomasz's new sharesTomasz ownsMaeve and Dario each own
€400,0002.9%35.3%32.4%
€100,00010.7%40.5%29.8%

At the higher value, the money moves the split a little. At the lower one, €12,000 turns an equal three-way split into one where Tomasz owns more than 40%. Neither value is right or wrong in itself. That is why the price has to be agreed by everyone and written down, and why a loan is usually simpler.

Unequal salaries between co-founders

Once there is money to pay salaries, founders' needs often differ. One has a mortgage and children, another can live on very little for a year. Say what each of you needs to live on, and from when, before the money arrives. How much a founder should pay themselves shows how to work out each founder's number. Co-founder expectations: the talk to have early has that conversation in it, and bootstrapping vs fundraising covers how little founders often take while customers pay for everything.

There are three common ways to handle different needs:

  1. The same salary for every founder, set at what the company can afford. Simple, and nobody keeps score. The founder who needs more has to find the gap elsewhere.
  2. Different salaries for a fixed period, written down. The founder who needs more is paid more. Write down that the extra pay reflects need and is no judgment on anyone's work, that the equity does not change, and the date you look at it again (the next raise, say).
  3. Pay owed for later. The founders who take less record the difference as owed. Be careful here. It creates a debt the company carries into its next round. In all three countries, pay owed has tax rules of its own (see below). Don't set this up without an accountant.

In the made-up example, Dario needs €3,000 a month and Maeve and Tomasz can manage on €2,000. They choose the second option for twelve months, write it down, and leave the equity alone.

A founder working part-time is a different case. That is a difference in time, not in need, and it can justify a different equity split, as the equity split page explains.

What the rules say in Ireland, the UK and the US

Founder loans, pay and expenses each have their own rules in each country. These are some of the points to raise with your accountant, not a full list.

Ireland

  • Lending to your company. When a director lends money to their own company, accountancy firm Forvis Mazars calls it "generally straightforward and low risk from a tax perspective". Document the loan, ideally with written terms, and record it in the company's accounts (its guide to director loans).
  • Founder salaries. Revenue says PAYE applies to directors in the same way as to any other employee, and the company must tell Revenue about each payment to a director no later than the day it pays it (Revenue on directors). Revenue adds that for what it calls proprietary directors, salary paid over six months after an accounting period ends is treated as paid on that period's final day. Ask your accountant how this applies to pay you record as owed.
  • Costs from before you started trading. Revenue's manual on pre-trading expenses allows a deduction for expenses incurred in the three years before the trade starts.

The UK

  • Lending to your company. GOV.UK says money you lend the company is not subject to Corporation Tax. Any interest you charge counts as a business expense for the company and as your personal income. The company deducts basic-rate Income Tax of 20% before paying you the interest, and reports it each quarter on form CT61 (GOV.UK on lending your company money).
  • Keep a director's loan account. GOV.UK says you must record every amount you take out of the company or put into it (GOV.UK on director's loans).
  • Founder salaries. GOV.UK lists company directors among the people not entitled to the National Minimum Wage (who gets the minimum wage). A director who also does other work for the company may have an employment contract and employment rights (GOV.UK on directors' employment status).
  • Pay owed for later. For a director, section 18 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 can treat salary as received when it is entered in the company's accounts or records, even if you can't draw it yet. So pay you record as owed can be taxed before you see it.
  • Costs from before you started trading. Section 61 of the Corporation Tax Act 2009 covers a company's trade expenses from up to 7 years before it started trading.

The US

  • Lending to your company. The IRS can treat money a shareholder calls a loan as stock instead. Section 385 of the tax code lists the factors that can decide it, among them a written promise to repay a fixed sum on a set date at a fixed interest rate, the company's debt compared with its equity, and whether the loan can convert into shares. Interest-free or low-interest loans between a corporation and a shareholder, in either direction, fall under section 7872 once they pass $10,000, and interest can be imputed. Ask a tax adviser how to write your note.
  • Founder salaries. The IRS treats a corporate officer as an employee in most cases, with tax withheld from their wages, unless they do little or no work and receive no pay (IRS on paying yourself). Under federal law, an employee who owns at least 20% of the business and actively manages it counts as an exempt executive, outside the minimum wage and overtime rules (Department of Labor fact sheet 17B). States have their own minimum wage laws (the Department of Labor's state list), so check yours.
  • Pay owed for later. A promise to pay salary in a later year can fall under section 409A of the tax code. If a deferred pay plan breaks its rules, the deferred amounts become taxable at once, with an extra 20% tax on top. Have a tax adviser set it up, or don't do it.
  • Costs from before you started. Section 195 of the tax code lets a business deduct up to $5,000 of start-up costs in its first year (less if they pass $50,000) and spread the rest over 180 months.

These rules cover the company's own costs before it starts trading. Whether costs a founder paid before the company existed can count is a question for your accountant.

In every country, the person who sets up your books should hear about every founder loan, every receipt and every salary arrangement before the first set of accounts. Have a lawyer draft anything that mixes money and shares.

What to write in your co-founder agreement

Keep it simple. The money part needs a few lines:

  • What each founder puts in at the start, and when.
  • That later costs are split equally.
  • That anything one founder puts in beyond that is a loan by default, repaid first, with its terms.
  • That shares are issued only if every founder agrees, at a price written down.
  • The spending limit for one founder alone.
  • Salaries: who gets what, from when, and when you look at it again.
  • When you zero out: the event or date when loans and receipts get paid back.
  • What happens to a founder's loan if they leave: when it is repaid and in what order. When a co-founder leaves your startup covers the rest of that conversation.

What to put in a co-founder agreement goes through the other parts: the split, vesting, what belongs to the company, and leaving. A lawyer where you incorporate should draft it.

When money turns into a fight

If you didn't write it down and a disagreement has started, begin by understanding where each founder stands, separately. Find out what each one thinks the money was, what they expected back, and where the two stories part. The fight may turn out to be about one amount that nobody named when it went in. How to resolve a co-founder dispute takes it from there.

Join 700+ founders who got personalized advice

Ready to Move Faster?

Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.

No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.