Skip to main content
Share:
What does a startup advisor do? Roles, pay and red flags

What does a startup advisor do? Roles, pay and red flags

What a startup advisor does, when you need one, how to pay them in equity, cash or both, and how to tell a good advisor from a bad one.

11 min read

A startup advisor is an experienced person you bring in to help with one part of your company, usually in exchange for a small share of it, a fee, or both. They don't work in the business every day, and they don't run it. They lend you their judgment and their contacts on the problems where you have neither.

So what does a startup advisor do in practice, when do you need one, and what should you pay? The short answer: hire an advisor for a job you can describe in one sentence, pay them in line with published ranges, make any equity vest, and test them on a real problem before you sign anything.

What does a startup advisor do?

Most advisors do one or more of these jobs:

  • Open doors in their field. They introduce you to customers, partners, hires or investors they know personally. A warm introduction from someone the other side trusts is often easier to say yes to than a cold email.
  • Cover a gap in the team. A market you don't know, a regulated sector, a kind of selling you've never done, or a first engineer you can't judge on your own.
  • Check big decisions before you make them. Your pricing, your first raise, a senior hire. They have seen how these go at other companies and can spot what you're missing.
  • Give you a regular outside view. A monthly call with someone outside the company, who asks the questions your team has stopped asking.

Just as important is what an advisor doesn't do. They don't make your decisions, do the work for you or manage your team. Treat their advice as input, never as orders: the decisions stay yours. How to get honest feedback on your startup idea covers what to do when two people you trust tell you opposite things.

Advisor, mentor or co-founder: the difference

Founders mix these three up, and the mix-up can cost them equity.

MentorAdvisorCo-founder
Where they come fromA startup program or your networkYou choose them for a set jobYou build the company together
What they getUsually nothingCash, a small share of the company, or bothA large share, earned over years
Time they giveWhatever the relationship allowsAn agreed amount, often a monthly meeting plus specific tasksMost of their working week
What's written downUsually nothingAn advisor agreementA co-founder agreement, with vesting

A mentor is usually free and comes through a program or your network. Mentorship is a relationship that grows over time, so how to find a startup mentor is a different question from hiring an advisor. An advisor is usually paid, in cash or a small share of the company, for a set job.

If someone will give most of their working week to the company from the start, they're a possible co-founder. The rules for how to split equity between co-founders apply to them, and the advisor ranges further down don't.

When you need a startup advisor, and when you don't

You need an advisor when you can name the gap and it is costing you. Try finishing this sentence: "We need someone who has ___, to help us ___ in the next six months." If you can fill both blanks, you have a job description, and you can go and look for the person.

Signs you need one:

  • You're about to sell into a market where you know nobody, and its buyers buy on trust.
  • Your next big decision is one nobody on the team has made before, such as a first raise or a first senior hire.
  • You keep losing weeks to a problem an experienced person would sort out in an afternoon.

Reasons that don't justify one:

  • To make your deck look stronger. At pre-seed, a row of advisor logos tends to make the real team look thin, which is why the 10-minute pitch deck outline leaves them off.
  • To have someone tell you what to do. A good advisor sharpens your thinking. The decisions stay with you.
  • Because the job is lonely. It is, and that is serious. What helps there is other founders going through the same thing, and you don't need to pay them. Where to find a startup founder community covers where they are.

How to pay a startup advisor: equity, cash or both

You can pay an advisor in equity, in cash, or with a mix of the two. The right one depends on the circumstances: the person, the job and the stage your company is at.

Equity. The best-known benchmark is the Founder Institute's FAST agreement (Founder/Advisor Standard Template), a free template for paying advisors in equity. These are its suggested stakes for one advisor:

Advisor's levelIdea stageStartup stageGrowth stage
Standard: monthly meetings0.25%0.20%0.15%
Expert: meetings, plus contacts and projects1.00%0.80%0.60%

In FAST's own example, an advisor who meets the team monthly, helps recruit and takes a customer call earns 1% of an early-stage company, against 0.6% for the same help at a growth-stage one. The stake is paid in restricted stock or options and vests over two years, with a three-month cliff. In practice, the cliff means that if the relationship isn't working, you can end it in the first three months without giving away any equity. The Founder Institute says FAST is meant for strategic advisors paid in equity, and isn't designed for project consulting or "work for hire".

These are one organization's suggestions. They make a sensible starting point, and a useful check when someone asks for five times as much.

Cash. Cash suits a job with a clear end: a pricing review, help getting ready for a raise, a few months of help with sales. You agree a fee for the project, or a monthly fee for a set amount of time. It costs money now, but you keep your equity, and the arrangement ends when the job does.

A mix of equity and cash. You can also combine the two: a very small equity stake plus a cash fee. This often comes up when an advisor who normally works only for cash believes in the founder and the startup, and offers a reduced fee because they're getting some equity. You pay less now, and the stake gives them a reason to care how it turns out.

A made-up example: three ways to pay the same advisor

Imagine two founders building booking software for wedding venues. Everything in this example is invented: the founders, the company and every number. They have a first version, and three venues use it for free. Neither founder has ever sold to venues, so they want someone who has spent years doing it.

They meet a former sales director from a group of venues. She is willing to meet them monthly, introduce them to venue owners she knows, and sit in on their first sales calls. They weigh three ways to pay her:

OptionWhat they offerWhat it costs them
Equity1%, vesting over two years with a three-month cliff (the top of FAST's range)No cash. 1% of the company if she stays two years
Cash€1,500 a month for six months€9,000, and no equity
Mix0.25%, vesting the same way, plus €750 a month for six months€4,500, and a quarter of the equity

They can't spare €9,000. She usually works only for cash, but she likes the founders and thinks venues need the product, so she suggests the mix. They write it down and agree to review it at the end of the cliff.

Advisor equity should vest

Whatever stake you agree, the advisor should earn it over time, the same way founders do. If you give someone 1% on day one and they disappear in month two, they can keep that 1% for good. How founder vesting works explains schedules and cliffs. For advisors, the schedule is usually shorter and the stake much smaller.

Put the deal in writing before the work starts. It needs:

  1. The job, in a sentence or two.
  2. How often you'll meet, and what else they'll do.
  3. What they get: cash, equity or both.
  4. The vesting schedule and the cliff.
  5. How either of you can end it, and what happens to unvested equity when you do.

FAST is a free starting point for the equity part, and the Founder Institute says you need no legal help to use it. Even so, giving someone shares or options has legal and tax effects in your company's country, so get it checked.

Advisor equity in Ireland, the UK and the US

The share option schemes with the best tax treatment are built for people who work a minimum number of hours a week for the company. An advisor on a monthly call doesn't.

Before anyone signs, you need two people. A lawyer in the country where your company is set up, to draft or check the advisor agreement and make sure the shares or options are issued properly under your company's own rules. And an accountant, to check the tax for the company and the advisor.

How to tell a good advisor from a bad one

Good signs:

  • They ask about your customers and your numbers before they give you any advice.
  • They have done the exact thing you need, recently, and can tell you how it went.
  • They tell you what they can't help with.
  • They're happy to work with you before anything is signed. The Founder Institute suggests at least a month together, and at least eight hours, before you discuss a FAST agreement.
  • They accept vesting and a cliff without a fuss. Someone who expects to add value has no reason to object.
  • The introductions they offer arrive in the first few weeks, without you chasing.

Warning signs:

  • They want a large stake, far above the ranges above, on day one and with no vesting.
  • They care more about appearing on your website and your deck than about your problems.
  • They say they "know everyone" but can't name the people they'd introduce you to.
  • They get annoyed when you hear their advice and decide differently.
  • They advise a direct competitor and don't tell you.

How to find a startup advisor

Start from the job, then look for the person who has done it. Good places to look:

  • People in the industry you sell into: former buyers, sales leaders and operators.
  • Mentors you met through a startup program who have already helped you.
  • Founders a few years ahead of you who solved the same problem.
  • Your investors' contacts, if you have investors.
  • Events where those people will be, picked carefully. How to network as a founder covers choosing events and booking calls ahead.

Then ask for help on one real problem before you offer anything. How they handle it tells you more than their CV does. If it goes well, the offer becomes an easy conversation.

Making it work once they say yes

Send a short update before each meeting: your numbers, what changed, and the one or two questions you want help with. Ask specific questions. "What do you think?" gets a general answer. "Should we charge venues per booking or a flat monthly fee?" gets a useful one.

Review the arrangement at the end of the cliff. If it isn't working, end it then, politely and in writing. If it is, tell your advisor what happened when you took their advice, and what happened when you didn't.

Join 700+ founders who got personalized advice

Ready to Move Faster?

Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.

No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.