Skip to main content
Share:
When to shut down a startup, and how to do it well

When to shut down a startup, and how to do it well

When to shut down a startup: the signs it's time, the signs to hold, a test to set in advance, and how to close well in Ireland, the UK and the US.

13 min read

When to shut down a startup? My answer: when you've talked to enough customers, tried both kinds of pivot, and still nobody will pay. Or when the money is running out, there's no realistic way to get more, and the founders can't cover their own basics. Not after one bad month, and not after one failed raise.

Make that call on an ordinary day, not the worst one, by deciding your test in advance: a date, and what has to be true by then.

I've been through it

I've shut down a company myself. Looking back at my first startup, the thing I'd do differently is the customer discovery: proper validation, and more conversations with customers. After that, other things got in the way. I had team issues and co-founder issues that eventually forced us to close. I had health issues and burnout. And I didn't reach product-market fit. So a company can shut down for many, many different reasons.

When to shut down a startup: the signs it's time

Nobody will pay, after enough conversations and both kinds of pivot

You've talked to enough people who have the problem that you've stopped hearing anything new. You've asked them to commit, with money, a signature or real time, and they haven't. Compliments and waitlist sign-ups don't count; how to validate a startup idea sets out what does.

At that point you've tested your first problem, a new solution to it, and a second problem, and the market has replied. When you name a real price and hear nothing back, that's the reply. How to price a new product makes the point: silence is the real no, and a lower price won't make the problem any bigger.

You never reach product-market fit, and every customer is a battle

This one is easy to miss, because from the outside the company looks alive. You have customers. You may have raised money. But each new customer takes a fight, and it never gets easier.

"Just because you have a business, just because you have customers, just because you have managed to raise a fund, if you're always looking to reach product-market fit, but you never reach it, and therefore acquiring new customers is always a struggle, you should think about it." That holds even after a pivot. Fit shows up as customers getting easier to win, and if the work so far hasn't made the next one any easier, more of the same probably won't either.

The money is running out, and nobody can cover their basics

You've looked hard for more cash (customers, investors, grants, cuts), and there's no realistic way to get it. And the founders can't pay their own bills.

Founder pay is the least each founder needs to live, and how much should a founder pay themselves makes the case that you should never be worried about money. When the company can't pay even that, and nothing ahead will change it, each extra month is paid for with your savings, your debt or your health.

The team, or your health, can't carry on

Co-founder fights that never get settled, a co-founder who leaves at the wrong moment, a team that falls apart. A founder's health. Burnout. Any of these can end a company, even one with customers. If the problems in why co-founders fall out have gone past fixing, and nobody else can take the work on, there may be no one left to run it.

If you're burned out right now, don't make this decision this week. The founder burnout guide says that if a big decision can wait until you've rested, you should let it wait.

The signs to hold

These hurt, and none of them is a reason to stop on its own:

  • One bad month. A big customer leaves, sales dip, a launch flops. Look at the trend over several months, not at one.
  • One failed raise. Investors say no for many reasons, and some have nothing to do with you: their stage, their sectors, a company like yours already in their portfolio. In my view, the majority of the time the reason is that you're too early. So a failed raise often means it was too early to raise, not that the business is dead. A failed round can also mean your business shouldn't raise at all; bootstrapping vs fundraising works through that question.

Pivot first?

Before you stop, check which kind of pivot you've tried. There are two, and they carry equal weight.

  • A solution pivot. The problem is real and painful, you validated it, but your solution is the wrong one. You keep the problem and change the solution.
  • A problem pivot. Your customers, your discovery and your conversations show you that you're solving the wrong problem. You move to the right one, and it needs a different solution.

If you've tried neither, try first. If you've tried one, ask honestly whether the other fits. If you've tried both and still nobody pays, that's the first sign above. When should a startup pivot? covers both kinds, with a made-up example of each.

When you've lost love for the problem, but the business works

In an early startup that isn't working yet, love for the problem is what gets you through the hard years. If you don't love it, sooner rather than later you'll quit; that's the first letter of the founder mindset, PURE. Losing it there is worth taking seriously. It's also one of the signs of burnout, so give it a chance to come back once you've rested.

But say the business already works. It's successful, profitable and moving forward well, and you simply don't care about the problem anymore. "If the business is successful, why would you shut down the business?" You don't need to shut down the business just because you no longer love the problem. Consider stepping down or changing roles instead. Someone else can run it. Customers keep a product they rely on, staff keep their jobs, and you keep your shares.

A made-up example: the tree surgery software

Imagine a founder who built quoting and scheduling software for tree surgeons. Everything in this example is invented, the numbers included. Six years in, 900 firms pay for it, the company is profitable, and 14 people work there.

She dreads the Monday meetings. Tree surgeons' quotes no longer interest her, and she'd rather start something new. Her first thought is to shut the company down.

Instead, she talks to her head of operations, who has run the day-to-day for two years and still loves the problem. Over six months he takes over as CEO, and she moves to the board. The company keeps growing, she keeps her shares, and she has her time back.

Set the test in advance

The worst time to decide is the day after a bad call, so decide before it comes.

  1. Pick a date. Far enough out to give the plan a fair run, close enough that the money lasts past it.
  2. Write what has to be true by then. A number you can check: paying customers, monthly revenue, a signed contract. "Traction" is not a number.
  3. Write what happens if it isn't. Stop, or one specific change with a new date. Not "we'll see".
  4. Agree it with your co-founders, and tell your investors. A test only you know about is easy to move.
  5. Leave it alone until the date. Check the numbers every month. Decide on the day.

Founder imposter syndrome and other fears suggests the same habit for the fear that it won't work: write down the test, the date and the result that would make you stop.

A made-up example: volunteer rotas for small festivals

Imagine two founders building software that plans volunteer shifts for small music festivals. Everything in this example is invented, the numbers included.

After 18 months they've talked to more than 40 festival organizers. Their app didn't sell, so they changed the solution and ran the rotas for festivals themselves. Then organizers kept describing a different problem, food traders who cancel at the last minute, so they built a tool for that. Organizers liked both. Very few paid.

In March they had €48,000 left and were spending €8,000 a month, with both founders already paid only their basics. They wrote their test: by June 30th, 12 festivals paying at least €8,000 each for next season, enough to cover a year of spending. If not, they close. They told their angel investor the same day.

In May the biggest festival they were talking to pulled out, and one of them wanted to quit that night. They didn't, because the date hadn't come. On June 30th they had four paying festivals, and two investors had said no to more money. They stopped, with €16,000 still in the bank to close properly.

How to shut down well

How you close follows you to the next company, because the investors, customers and staff who watch you close may be the people you work with again.

  1. Get advice before you announce anything. Talk to an accountant. If the company may not be able to pay everything it owes, talk to an insolvency professional or a lawyer too, because that changes what you're allowed to do.
  2. Tell your investors early, while there's cash left, not in the last week. They may know a buyer for the customers or the code, or someone who'd hire the team. On the standard US (Y Combinator) SAFE, if the company shuts down, the investor is owed their money back, ranking behind creditors, so what's left in the bank matters to them too (how a SAFE works).
  3. Look after your staff and what you owe. Pay final wages, and follow the rules on redundancy where you are. If the company can't pay everyone, don't choose who gets paid yourself; that's what the professional in step 1 is for.
  4. Give customers notice, and help them leave. Tell them the date the product stops, give them their data in a form they can use somewhere else, and consider refunding what they've paid for and won't get.
  5. Keep the records: accounts, contracts, payroll and tax filings, for as long as the rules below say.
  6. Look after yourself. A shutdown is a loss, and it's tiring. If your startup fails, the startup failed, not you, as startup mistakes to avoid puts it. Take real time off before you decide what's next.

Closing the company in Ireland, the UK and the US

In every country, the route depends on one question: can the company pay its debts? Get an accountant before you decide, and an insolvency professional or lawyer if the answer might be no. What follows is what the official pages say, not legal or tax advice.

Ireland

  • If the company has stopped trading and owes next to nothing, it can apply for voluntary strike-off. Revenue says it applies to companies that have ceased to trade or never traded, and that the company must give the Companies Registration Office (CRO) a letter of no objection from Revenue. It says to apply only once tax returns up to the date you stopped are filed and there are no outstanding tax liabilities (Revenue on voluntary strike-off).
  • The conditions are in the law. Section 731 of the Companies Act 2014 requires, among other things, a certificate from each director that the company's assets and its liabilities are each no more than €150 and that it isn't in ongoing or pending litigation, plus an advertisement in a daily newspaper within 30 days before the application (Companies Act 2014, section 731).
  • If the company can't pay its debts, it can't meet those conditions. Under section 586 of the same Act, a creditors' voluntary winding up can start with the company in general meeting resolving that it can't continue its business because of its liabilities (section 586). A creditors' meeting follows, and if the creditors and the company nominate different liquidators, the creditors' choice wins (section 588). Talk to an insolvency practitioner before any of this.

The UK

  • It depends on whether the company can pay its bills. GOV.UK says a solvent company can be struck off or put into a members' voluntary liquidation, and striking off is usually the cheapest. When a company is insolvent, "the interests of the people your company owes money to (its 'creditors') legally come before those of the directors or shareholders", and the options include administration, strike-off and a creditors' voluntary liquidation (GOV.UK on closing a limited company).
  • Strike-off is not a way out of your debts. Companies House says it "is not an alternative to formal insolvency proceedings", that creditors could apply to have a struck-off company restored, and that applying when the company isn't eligible is an offence (Companies House guidance on strike off).
  • The strike-off steps. The application is form DS01 and costs £18. You must send a copy within 7 days to anyone who could be affected, including shareholders, creditors and employees. Anything left in the company when it's struck off goes to the Crown, and you keep business documents for 7 years afterwards (GOV.UK on striking off a company).
  • If staff are owed money by an insolvent company, GOV.UK says they can apply to the government for things like a redundancy payment, holiday pay, unpaid wages and statutory notice pay (your rights if your employer is insolvent).

The US

  • Dissolution is state by state. The SBA says to file dissolution documents with every state you're registered in, and that failing to legally dissolve an LLC or corporation leaves you exposed to continued taxes and filing requirements. It also points to the federal WARN Act (SBA on closing your business), which the Department of Labor says "helps ensure advance notice in cases of qualified plant closings and mass layoffs" (Department of Labor on WARN). Check your own state's rules.
  • The federal tax side. The IRS checklist says you must file a final return for the year you close. A corporation must also file Form 966 if it adopts a resolution or plan to dissolve. If you have employees, you must pay them final wages and compensation owed and make the final federal tax deposits, and keep employment tax records for at least four years (IRS on closing a business).

After

Rest first. Then write down what you'd do differently while it's fresh.

If you start again, start from the problem. The first-time founder guide sets out the order I'd follow: love the problem, validate it, then build.

Join 700+ founders who got personalized advice

Ready to Move Faster?

Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.

No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.