Skip to main content
Share:
How to break a 50/50 co-founder deadlock

How to break a 50/50 co-founder deadlock

Two founders at 50/50 and a decision neither will drop: how to prevent a tie, the tie-break ladder to sign, the shotgun clause, and the law.

13 min read

You and your co-founder own half the company each. A big decision is on the table, one of you says yes, the other says no, and nobody has the votes to settle it. That is a 50/50 co-founder deadlock, and while it lasts, the decision doesn't get made.

Below: how to break a 50/50 co-founder deadlock, and how to stop most of them before they start. First, who can settle a tie by default, and how to prevent one. Then the tie-break ladder to write into your agreement, what to do if you're stuck today, the shotgun clause as a last resort, and what the law offers in Ireland, the UK and the US when nothing was signed. At the end, a made-up example walks two founders up the ladder.

Why a 50/50 co-founder deadlock happens

An equal split is the right place to start, because almost all the work is still ahead of you, and how to split equity between co-founders explains why. The catch is the vote. At 50/50, neither of you has a majority. Unless whoever chairs the meeting has a casting vote (the next section explains), a vote fails if one of you votes no. How to remove a co-founder sets out what that means in law, in Ireland, the UK and Delaware, and the court routes that are left. Many deadlocks never reach a formal vote, though. One of you wants to do something, the other refuses, and the company waits. So keep the equal split, and add a rule for what happens when you tie.

Who chairs matters: the casting vote

A casting vote is a second vote the chair of a meeting gets when the votes are tied. In a 50/50 company, that means whoever chairs can settle a tie, so in practice you're no longer 50/50.

  • Ireland. The chair of a directors' meeting has a casting vote (section 160). So does the chair of a general meeting, unless the company's constitution says otherwise (section 187). The directors can elect their own chair, and the chair of the board also chairs general meetings. If there is no chair, the directors present pick one of themselves.
  • The UK. The model articles for private companies let the directors appoint a chair, and give whoever chairs a directors' meeting a casting vote (article 13), unless, under the articles, the chair isn't counted for quorum or voting purposes. They give no casting vote at a meeting of shareholders. The model articles apply unless your articles change them (section 20 of the Companies Act 2006). Law firm Setfords points out that at a 50/50 board, choosing the chair is itself a decision the two of you have to agree on, and that many 50/50 companies take the casting vote out.

Setfords also describes bringing in a neutral person to chair meetings or sit on the board as a third director, so neither founder holds the deciding vote. Ask your lawyer three things: who chairs your meetings, whether your constitution or articles give that person a casting vote, and what you'd want to change. In the US, ask what your bylaws or operating agreement say. Whatever you choose, it works alongside the ladder below, not in place of it.

Prevent most ties: one owner for each area

Most decisions shouldn't need both of you. From day one, agree who has the final say in each area: product, sales and money, at least. That founder hears the other out on anything big, then decides. When two owners' areas collide and you can't agree, the CEO decides.

Don't split the final say on an area down the middle. If both of you have to agree, every decision in that area can become a tie. Co-founder roles and responsibilities shows how to pick an owner for each area and fit it all on one page.

That leaves a short list of decisions you make together, and these are where a 50/50 company can still tie: raising money, selling the company, spending over a limit you set, and anything else you agreed to share, such as the direction of the company or bringing in a new co-founder.

The tie-break ladder for decisions you share

For those shared decisions, agree now, while you're getting on, what happens when you can't agree. The ladder I'd write into your co-founder agreement has three rungs. You only climb to the next rung if the one before didn't settle it.

  1. A cooling-off period, then a second conversation. Stop arguing and wait a set number of days. Each of you writes down your case: what you want, why, and what worries you about the other option. Then sit down again. Some ties loosen once neither of you is defending a position you took in the heat of the moment.
  2. A trusted advisor or board member you both chose in advance. Name them in the agreement, before any of this comes up, because agreeing on someone mid-argument is much harder. Pick someone with no stake in the answer: not a friend of one of you, not an investor who gains from one side. They should hear each of you alone before they hear you together. Decide now, in writing, whether their view settles it or is only advice. If it settles it, the ladder ends here. Other guides here say to go with their view, which is this ladder with the mediator left out. Add the mediator if you want their view to be advice, not the last word.
  3. A professional mediator. A mediator doesn't decide for you. They help the two of you reach your own agreement, which can work even when talking alone has stalled. Mediators charge for their time, so agree in the clause how you split the fee. The country sections below say where to find one.

Two more points go with the ladder. They're common sense, not extra rungs.

  • A time limit on each rung. Some decisions come with a deadline, such as an investor's offer. If the ladder takes longer than the deadline, the decision is made for you.
  • What happens if every rung fails. Usually the decision doesn't go ahead, and things stay as they are. Write that down, so both of you know that "no" is where a tie ends up.

In plain words, the clause your lawyer drafts might read like this:

If we can't agree on a decision we make together: (1) each of us writes our case, we wait 7 days, and we meet again; (2) if we still disagree, we put it to [name] within 14 days, who hears each of us alone, and whose view is [advice / final]; (3) if we still disagree, we go to a professional mediator within 30 days and split the fee equally. If we still disagree after that, the decision does not go ahead.

The numbers in that sample are placeholders, and so is the last line. Agree both with your lawyer, and pick numbers that fit how fast your decisions move.

If you're already stuck

If you never wrote a ladder and you're in a tie right now, don't start by arguing the decision again. Start by understanding both sides separately: where each of you stands, what each of you expected, what you each want to achieve, and where you each want the company to go. That shows where the disagreement actually is, which is often somewhere other than the argument you've been having. How to resolve a co-founder dispute takes you through it step by step.

Then check whose decision it is. If it sits in one founder's area, that founder decides. If two areas collide, the CEO decides. Only a decision you truly make together needs the ladder. If you have no ladder, agree one now, for this decision, before you go back to the substance. Agreeing how to decide is much easier than agreeing what to decide.

The shotgun clause, as a last resort

A buy-sell clause, often called a shotgun clause, works like this: one founder names a price for their shares, and the other must either buy at that price or sell their own shares at it. Law firm Setfords, writing about England and Wales, lists it among the deadlock mechanisms a shareholders' agreement can hold, under the name "Russian roulette or shotgun clause".

It ends the deadlock. It usually ends the partnership too, because one of you leaves. So keep it for the very end, after the ladder, and only ever drafted by a lawyer. Before you sign one, think about who could actually pay. If one of you has savings and the other doesn't, the founder with money can name a low price. The other can't afford to buy, so has to sell at it. That can make the clause unfair, so ask your lawyer how to guard against it. If you do part ways, the founder vesting guide explains how much of the company each of you has earned so far, which shapes any price.

What the law offers when nothing was signed

With no clause and no ladder, a tie that no casting vote settles has no quick answer in law. What the law offers are court cases, which mean a lawyer, months of your time and a large bill. The removal guide linked above sets out the main ones. A few more points, country by country.

Ireland

The court can wind up a company if it thinks it is just and equitable to do so (section 569 of the Companies Act 2014). That ends the company along with the tie. Before a solicitor starts court proceedings for you, the Mediation Act 2017 requires them to advise you to consider mediation and give you information about mediation services (section 14). The Mediators' Institute of Ireland has a directory of mediators, including civil and commercial ones.

The UK

In England, Wales and Scotland, the court can wind up a company if it thinks that is just and equitable (section 122 of the Insolvency Act 1986). Here too, that ends the company. The Civil Mediation Council lists the mediators it regulates.

The US

Company law is state law, so the answer depends on where you incorporated. For an LLC, start with what its operating agreement says. In Delaware, when a corporation has two stockholders who each own 50% and run it as a joint venture, and they can't agree on whether to end the venture and dispose of its assets, either one can petition the Court of Chancery, unless the certificate of incorporation or a written stockholder agreement says otherwise. If they don't agree a plan within the time the law sets, the court can dissolve the company (section 273 of title 8). The American Arbitration Association runs mediation for business disputes, partnership disputes included.

Where you need a lawyer

Have a lawyer in the country where your company is set up draft the deadlock clause, ladder and any shotgun clause included. Ask them to check it fits your company's constitution (Ireland), articles (the UK), or bylaws or operating agreement (the US), because if the two documents say different things, you'll end up arguing about which one wins. And as soon as you're 50/50 and stuck on something that touches shares, see one before you sign anything.

A made-up example: the bookshop software

Imagine two founders, Ines and Callum, building preorder and event-ticketing software for independent bookshops. Everything in this example is invented: the people, the company and every number.

They own half each, both are directors, and Ines is CEO and owns money. Callum owns product. When they incorporated, their lawyer wrote a ladder into their agreement: five days to cool off and talk again, then seven days for an advisor they both named (a founder they've known for years, whose view is advice only), then a mediator within 14 days. If every rung fails, the decision doesn't go ahead. They also signed a shotgun clause. Their lawyer also made sure neither of them can settle a tie just by chairing a meeting.

Twenty months in, 90 bookshops pay them every month, and a seed fund offers €500,000 for 20% of the company. The offer is open for three weeks. Ines wants to take it and hire two developers. Callum says no: they're close to covering their costs, and he doesn't want to give a fund a say in the company. Raising money is a decision they make together, so it's a tie. Bootstrapping vs fundraising is the question they're stuck on.

Rung 1. Each writes a page. At the second conversation, Ines finds out that Callum's real worry is losing control of the product. Callum finds out that Ines thinks a bigger competitor will take their market within a year. Both feel heard, and neither moves.

Rung 2. The advisor talks to each of them alone. She comes back with something neither had said out loud: Ines wants to build a large company, and Callum wants a small, profitable one. She suggests a smaller raise. Ines would take it. Callum won't. Her view is advice, so it doesn't settle anything.

Where it breaks. Twelve days have gone, and the earliest mediator they can book is two weeks away, past the fund's deadline. The fund won't wait. Without an agreement they can't accept, so the offer lapses. The ladder did its job on the decision: they knew in advance where a tie ends up, and nobody had to win an argument. What it couldn't fix is that they want different companies, and when co-founders disagree on direction, one decision at a time won't settle it.

So they go to mediation anyway, about the future rather than the round. There they agree that one of them should buy the other out. They have the shotgun clause, but Callum has savings and Ines has none, so whoever names a price, Callum is the only one who could buy. They don't use it. With the mediator's help they agree a price for Ines's shares, paid over two years, after their lawyer reads their vesting terms and an accountant checks the tax.

What they'd change next time: time limits short enough to fit a real investor deadline, and, before signing anything, the talk about co-founder expectations, including what kind of company each of them wants to build.

Join 700+ founders who got personalized advice

Ready to Move Faster?

Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.

No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.