
How to resolve a co-founder dispute, step by step
Stuck in a dispute with your co-founder? Six steps in order: hear each side alone, find the real disagreement, check who decides, and when to get help.
If you are reading this, you and your co-founder are probably stuck. A decision has turned into an argument, the argument has gone on for weeks, and the rest of the company can feel it.
Here is how to resolve a co-founder dispute, in order. It starts with the step most founders skip: before you try to settle anything, understand where each of you stands, separately. At the end: who to bring in when you can't do it alone, and what to do when one of you should go.
How to resolve a co-founder dispute: first, stop the damage
Do these today, before the real conversation.
- Keep it between the founders. Don't argue in front of the team, and don't pass messages through an employee, an investor or a friend you share. People pick sides, and then the dispute has more than two people in it.
- Don't decide the big thing in the heat. If the decision can wait a week, let it wait. If it can't, make the smallest call that keeps the company moving, and agree to come back to it.
- Book the time. Pick a slot in the next few days for one proper conversation with nothing else on the agenda.
Step 1: Understand each side, separately
When co-founders are in a dispute, my first step is to understand both sides: where each one stands, what they expected, what they want to achieve and where they want the company to go. That shows where the disagreement actually is. I start separately, with each co-founder on their own, to get each one's view before anyone talks it through together.
You can do this yourselves, without anyone else in the room. Each of you writes one page, alone, answering four questions:
- Where do I stand? My position on this decision, in two or three sentences.
- What did I expect? What I assumed about how this would be decided, or how we would work, that has not happened.
- What am I trying to achieve? What this decision protects or gets, for me and for the company.
- Where do I want the company to go? In one year and in three.
Swap pages before you meet, and read the other one twice.
You are ready for step 2 when each of you can explain the other's position well enough that the other says, "Yes, that's it."
Step 2: Find where the disagreement actually is
Put the two pages side by side and look for where they differ. It is often not where the argument has been.
A fight about a product decision can be about one of you feeling left out of product decisions. A fight about a hire can be about money: one of you has no salary and is watching the bank balance. A fight about this quarter's plan can be about what kind of company you are building. The argument on the surface is the one you can see. The one underneath keeps coming back until you deal with it.
Your four answers usually show which layer it is:
- Different "where I stand", same "where I want to go": you disagree about one decision. This is the easiest kind to settle.
- Different "what I expected": one of you assumed something the other never agreed to. Co-founder expectations covers the assumptions that most often cause this.
- Different "where I want to go": you disagree about direction. When co-founders disagree on direction covers that conversation.
Most fights come from a short list of causes, and why co-founders fall out goes through them. If yours is about money one of you put in or takes out, who pays for what between co-founders is the place to look.
You are ready for step 3 when you can both finish the sentence "We are really disagreeing about..." the same way.
Step 3: Talk it through, and listen first
Now meet. One of you speaks and finishes without being interrupted. The other repeats back what they heard, until the first says it is right, and only then gives their own view. Then you swap.
Two habits make this work. First, ask open questions. "Do you have a problem with the roadmap?" gets a yes or a no, and it puts the other person on the defensive. "What concerns do you have about the roadmap?" gets the actual concern. Second, pause before you reply, even when you want to fire back. People often add the most important part when you give them room.
Watch for what is not said, too. A co-founder who says "fine" with folded arms is often not fine. Ask again, gently.
You may still disagree after this step. What should have changed is the tone: both of you feel heard, and you are arguing about the problem.
Step 4: Check whose decision it is
Many co-founder disputes drag on because nobody knows who gets to decide. Settle that before you argue about the answer again. If you have written down co-founder roles and responsibilities, the answer is on that page:
- It sits in one founder's area (product, sales, money). That founder makes the call once they have properly heard the other, who says plainly where they disagree and then backs the result.
- It sits where two owners' areas collide. You each put your case on half a page and wait a night. If neither of you has moved, the CEO settles it.
- It is one of the decisions you make together: direction, raising money and its terms, a new co-founder, or a sale. Here the tie rule you agreed applies: a vote if there are three or more of you, or, with two, the view of the third person you named on your page ahead of time.
If you never agreed any of this, agree it now, for this decision, before you go back to the substance. Agreeing how you will decide is much easier than agreeing what to decide.
Check two more things. Your co-founder agreement, or your shareholders' agreement if you have one, may say how disagreements get handled. If it does, follow it, and if the dispute touches shares, ask a lawyer what the agreement means for you. And if you have raised money, read what you signed with your investors: it may give them a say in some decisions.
Move on when you both know who makes the final call on this, and how.
Step 5: Split it into parts and start with the easiest
A big dispute is usually several smaller ones tied together. List every point you disagree on, then start with the one you are closest to agreeing on. One early agreement gets you both working on the problem again.
Where you can, agree what would settle a point before you argue the point itself: a number, a test, a customer's answer. "We never let cash fall below three months of costs" is easier to agree on than "Should we sign this deal?", and once it is agreed, it often answers the bigger question for you. The idea comes from Getting to Yes, by Roger Fisher and William Ury, which calls it using objective criteria. The same book separates the position someone defends from what they need underneath it, which is what step 2 looks for.
Write each point down in a shared note as soon as you agree it, so nobody has to rely on memory later. If the talk gets heated, stop and pick it up the next morning. An overnight pause costs you a day.
You have finished this step when you have a written list of what you agreed and a shorter list of what is still open.
The supermarket deal
Here is an invented case, figures and all. Mei and Jonas are a year into an online shop selling refill packs of household cleaning products. Jonas owns sales and customers. Mei is CEO and owns money.
A regional supermarket chain offers to stock them in 200 stores. It needs €30,000 of stock up front and pays 90 days after delivery. Jonas says yes. Mei says no. They argue for three weeks, some of it in front of their two employees.
Their pages show why. Mei expected any deal that ties up cash to come to her first, and €30,000 is most of the money in the bank. Jonas expected sales deals to be his call, and he wants shelf space to show investors in a seed round next year.
They both want to be in shops one day, so the supermarket is not the real disagreement. They disagree about whose call a sales deal is when it ties up cash, which their one-page split of roles never covered, and about whether to raise money next year at all.
They take the easy part first and agree that cash never drops below three months of costs. That rules out €30,000 now and points to a test: Jonas asks the chain for a trial in 20 stores with €3,000 of stock, and the chain agrees. They add a line to their page: any deal that ties up more than €5,000 of cash is Mei's call, as owner of money, after she has heard Jonas out. Whether to raise is a decision they make together, so if they can't agree on it, it goes to the third person named on their page.
Step 6: Write down the outcome and set a date
When it is settled, write down what you decided, who does what next, and when you will look at it again. Fix any gap the dispute showed in your working agreements, like Mei and Jonas's missing line on cash, and keep the date. A month later, neither of you should remember the decision differently.
When you can't settle it yourselves
If you have been through the steps and are still stuck, bring in someone neutral. Choose them together. You need someone you both trust who has no stake in the outcome: an experienced founder you both know, say, or a mentor from a program you are both in. Avoid anyone closer to one of you than the other, an investor who gains from one answer, and anyone who works for you.
Ask them to start where step 1 starts: one conversation with each of you, alone, before any meeting with both. Their first job is to understand both sides and find where the disagreement is. If your tie rule names them, you then go with their view. If it doesn't, agree before they start whether their view is advice or a decision.
When the dispute is about shares or a lot of money, or you can no longer talk without fighting, consider a professional mediator. Mediators charge for their time, so ask the fee before you start and agree how you will split it. Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own mediation bodies. Elsewhere, to find one:
- In Ireland, the Mediators' Institute of Ireland has a directory of mediators.
- In England and Wales, the Civil Mediation Council lists the mediators it regulates.
- In the US, the American Arbitration Association runs mediation for business disputes and has a mediator search.
A mediator helps the two of you reach your own agreement. Advice on your rights, about shares, the company or a contract, is a lawyer's job, in the country where your company is set up.
When the honest answer is that one of you should leave
Sometimes the steps show that the disagreement is bigger than one decision. You want different companies, or one of you no longer wants to do the work, and that is not going to change. Then the useful question is how to part well.
If you both see it, when a co-founder leaves covers how to do it with the company and the relationship intact. If one of you keeps not delivering and won't go, how to remove a co-founder covers that harder conversation. Either way, what you agreed on founder vesting sets how much of the company the one who leaves keeps.
Continue Reading
More in Co-foundersReady to Move Faster?
Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.
No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.


