Skip to main content
Share:
How to get honest feedback on your startup idea

How to get honest feedback on your startup idea

Why mentors, investors and other founders go easy on you, how to ask so they don't, and what to do when two mentors give you opposite advice.

11 min read

Ask ten people "What do you think of my idea?" and most of them will say something kind. A kind answer costs them nothing. An honest one means disappointing you, sitting through an awkward few minutes and thinking hard about a business they barely know. So the praise tells you little about the idea.

You get honest feedback on your startup idea by asking the right people a narrower question, making the critical answer the easy one to give, and then deciding for yourself what to do with it. This page covers feedback from mentors, investors and other founders, including what to do when two mentors tell you opposite things. Customers need a different kind of conversation, and customer interview questions for startups covers that one.

Why people are polite instead of honest

Most people who go easy on you have a sensible reason for it.

  • Praise is cheap and criticism is expensive. You're excited and they like you. Saying the idea has a hole in it risks spoiling that, and a compliment ends the conversation nicely.
  • A vague question gets a vague answer. "What do you think?" asks for a verdict on everything at once. Nobody can give that in five minutes, so they give a general, friendly one.
  • They don't know enough to be specific. A mentor who heard your pitch once can't tell whether your pricing is wrong. When people aren't sure, they hedge, and hedging sounds like encouragement.
  • Investors have their own reasons to stay vague. A detailed reason for saying no can turn into a debate they don't want, and some may prefer to keep the door open in case you come back stronger. "It's a bit early for us" can be the short, polite version of something more specific.
  • You make it hard without meaning to. If you defend every point as it comes, people soon learn that criticism isn't welcome, and they stop offering it.

The last one is yours to fix, so start there.

Who to ask, and what each one can tell you

Different people can be honest about different things. Ask each one about what they know.

WhoGood forCan't tell you
Mentors and advisorsDecisions they've made before: pricing, hiring, a first raise, a market they knowWhether your customers want this
InvestorsWhether the company fits what investors back, and what would hold up a dealWhether the business is good. A no can be about their fund, not about you
Other foundersWhat the next year or two looks like, which shortcuts worked, which mistakes cost themYour market, unless they sell to the same customers
CustomersWhether the problem is real, and whether they'll pay to have it fixedHow to build the company

Only the last row can tell you whether the idea works. A mentor who says "people will love this" is guessing, however much experience they have. How to validate a startup idea covers what counts as proof, and none of it is anyone's opinion.

The rest of this page is about the first three rows. If you don't have a mentor yet, how to find a startup mentor covers where to look. If you need someone paid to do a set job, read what a startup advisor does.

How to get honest feedback on your startup idea: five habits

1. Ask one narrow question

Name the part you want feedback on, and ask about that part only. A narrow question is easier to answer honestly, because the person has to judge one thing.

  • Instead of "What do you think of the idea?", ask "Which part of this would you push back on first?"
  • Instead of "Is our pitch any good?", ask "Where did you lose interest?"
  • Instead of "Any thoughts on pricing?", ask "We charge €200 a month per site. When you sold something similar, what did you charge, and how did buyers react?"

The last one asks about something they did, and a real experience is harder to soften than an opinion.

2. Ask for the bad news on purpose

Make the critical answer the expected one. "If this company has shut down in two years, what's the most likely reason?" "What's the first question an investor will ask that we can't answer yet?" Questions like these give people permission to be blunt. You asked for the problem, so naming it is helping you, and nobody has to feel rude.

3. Give them something real to react to

Feedback on an idea that lives in your head is mostly feedback on how well you described it. Bring something concrete: the deck, last month's numbers, a screen from the product, a customer's own words. Keep it short. A pitch built on the 3-minute pitch outline is a good length for anyone giving you their time for free.

4. Listen, write it down, and don't defend

While they talk, your only jobs are to understand and to take notes. If they've got a fact wrong, correct it in one sentence and move on. Then ask two follow-up questions: "Why do you think that?" and "What would change your mind?" The first answer tells you what they've seen. The second tells you what evidence would settle it. Save any disagreement for later, when you make your decision.

5. Tell them what you did

A week or two later, send a short note: what you changed, or why you didn't. People who see their honest answer taken seriously give you another one next time. When feedback disappears without a trace, people stop bothering.

How to sort what you hear

Honest feedback still isn't an instruction. Sort it before you act on it.

  • One person is an opinion. Three people saying the same thing separately is a pattern. Act on patterns. Note single opinions and watch whether they come back.
  • Weigh it by what the person knows. Someone who sold to your customers last year knows more about your sales problem than a well-known investor who never has.
  • Separate what they noticed from what they suggest. "I couldn't tell who pays" is something they noticed, and it's almost always worth fixing. "You should charge per user" is their fix, and it's one option among several.
  • Don't rewrite everything after every meeting. A deck that changes after each conversation tends to get more polished and less honest. Collect what you hear for a few weeks, then change things once.

How to get honest feedback from investors

Investors see a lot of pitches, so their reaction is useful even when they say no. You have to collect it the right way.

Write down every question they ask. Questions show where someone got stuck or stopped believing you. A question that three investors ask is a gap in your pitch: answer it in the deck next time, before anyone has to ask.

After a no, ask one short question. Reply in plain text, thank them, and ask something they can answer in a line: "What would you need to see for this to be worth another look?" or "Was it about us, or about where we are right now?" Don't argue with the answer, and don't ask twice. Some investors won't give you more than a line, and that's fine. Keep the reply as plain as your first email; how to cold email investors covers the format and when to stop following up.

A no can be about the fund, not about you. A fund may only invest at a certain stage or in certain sectors, may already back a company like yours, or may be near the end of what it can invest. So give a "not for us" little weight, and give a specific reason ("we don't think enough customers have this problem") a lot more.

One investor's opinion is one opinion. If you have co-founders, talk investor feedback through together before you change anything, and give investors one answer. Bootstrapping vs fundraising: how to decide covers how co-founders run a raise together.

How to get honest feedback from other founders

Other founders are often the most direct people you'll ask. They have nothing to sell you, and they've already made the mistakes you're about to make.

Two kinds are worth asking. Founders a year or two ahead of you can tell you what's coming. Founders at your own stage are the best people to trade with: you look at their pitch, they look at yours, and you're both blunt because you both need it.

Ask them what they did, as well as what they think of your plans: "How did you price your first contract?" "What would you do differently about your first hire?" If you don't have founders like this around you yet, where to find a startup founder community covers where they gather.

When two mentors tell you opposite things

This is common, for example in a startup program, where you might see several mentors in one week. One says raise now and the other says wait. One says go after big customers and the other says start small.

Start from this: advice is input, not orders, and you make the call. Neither mentor is responsible for your company, and neither of them will live with the result. When their advice conflicts, don't simply follow the more senior one, and don't split the difference. Go back to your customers and let them settle it.

In practice:

  1. Write each piece of advice in one line, with the reason behind it. If you don't know the reason, ask. Often the two mentors are picturing a different customer, a different stage or a company they once ran, and once you see that, the disagreement shrinks.
  2. Find the fact that decides it. Ask yourself what would have to be true for the first mentor to be right, and what for the second. Usually it's something about your customers, such as how they buy or what the problem costs them today.
  3. Go and find that fact. Talk to the customers it depends on, or run the smallest test that answers it. A handful of conversations is often enough.
  4. Decide, then tell both mentors what you decided and why. A good mentor would rather see you decide from evidence than follow them without it.

A made-up example: two mentors, one decision

Imagine two founders building software that helps care homes fill last-minute staff shifts without calling an agency. Everything in this example is invented, including every number. They're in a startup program, and in the same week two mentors give them opposite advice.

The first mentor says: "Go after the big care home groups. One contract could cover 40 homes." The second says: "Stay with independent homes. The big groups take a year or more to sign anything, and you'll run out of money waiting."

The founders write down the fact behind each piece of advice. The first mentor is right if a group can sign fast enough for the company to survive the wait. The second is right if independent homes will pay enough to keep the company going in the meantime.

So they make calls. Three operations managers at care home groups describe the same process: a pilot needs head office approval, then a formal tender, and the earliest any of them could sign is next autumn. Eight managers of independent homes say they spend around €2,000 a month on agency staff for last-minute cover, and five of them agree to a paid one-month pilot.

So they start with independent homes and leave the groups for later, when they have pilot results to show. They write to both mentors with what they found and what they decided. The first mentor offers to introduce them to a care home group once the pilots are done.

Join 700+ founders who got personalized advice

Ready to Move Faster?

Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.

No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.