Skip to main content
Share:
How to find a startup mentor: ask for advice first

How to find a startup mentor: ask for advice first

Where founders find a startup mentor, what to send first, and how one specific question grows into a mentor relationship over a few months.

8 min read

The quickest way to find a startup mentor is a startup program, because the mentors come with it. Outside a program, you find one by asking an experienced person for help with one specific problem, coming back to tell them what you did, and asking again when the next problem comes up. "Will you be my mentor?" comes last.

I mentor in more than 25 startup programs and have mentored about 700 founders. When you're looking for a mentor on your own, you won't get one from the first call. Mentorship is a relationship, and it starts with a question small enough to answer.

What a mentor is, and how a mentor differs from an advisor

A mentor is an experienced person who helps you think through problems as they come up, over months or years. A mentor is usually free and comes through a program or your network. An advisor is usually paid, in cash or a small share of the company, for a set job.

So if you need someone to commit to a specific piece of work, such as opening doors in a market you don't know, you're looking for an advisor, and what a startup advisor does covers when you need one and how to pay them. A mentor gives their time for free, so the relationship has to work for both of you, and that takes a while to build.

Before you look: write down what you need help with

Write down the two or three problems you're stuck on right now, one sentence each. That list tells you who to look for. Someone who has built a sales team can't help much with a product question, however impressive they are. It also gives you your first question.

The question has to be specific. A vague one asks the other person to do your thinking. A specific one shows you've done it, and it can be answered in one call.

VagueSpecific
"Can I pick your brain about my startup?""Our first customers keep asking for a feature we hadn't planned. How did you decide when to build what customers asked for?"
"Any advice on fundraising?""We're deciding whether to raise this year or keep growing on revenue. What would you want to know before making that call?"
"Could you help us with sales?""Our trials go well, but buyers take months to sign. Where would you look first?"

Have one sentence ready on what your company does. Almost everyone you ask will want it before they answer anything, and startup one-liner examples, and how to write yours shows how to write it.

Where to find a startup mentor

Startup programs

Accelerators, incubators, pre-accelerators, and programs run by universities, governments and large companies often bring in mentors: experienced founders, operators, investors and specialists. The format varies. Some programs give you set mentor sessions or office hours, and others have a pool of mentors you book time with.

This is the quickest route because the mentors have already agreed to help founders like you. You don't start from zero. But a mentor in a program sees a lot of founders, so the relationship still has to be built. Treat each session as the start of one, and follow up afterwards the same way you would with anyone else (see the steps below).

If mentors are part of why you're applying, check what the mentoring involves before you do: who the mentors are, how you get time with them, and whether you can still reach them once the program ends. Founders from earlier cohorts will tell you how it worked in practice, and are startup accelerators worth it? lists what to ask them.

Warm introductions

Someone who knows both of you can introduce you: an investor, another founder, a former manager, a mentor from a program. Ask for an introduction to one person, for one question. Make it easy for them by sending a short note they can forward as it is, with your one-line description and the question you'd like to ask.

People you approach yourself

Good people to approach are founders a few years ahead of you who have solved the problem you have now, and people who used to work in the industry you sell into. You'll meet some of them at events, if you pick the events carefully: how to network as a founder explains how to pick which ones to go to and set up calls before you arrive. Others you'll meet in a founder community, where founders a few years ahead often help the ones just starting; where to find a startup founder community covers where to look.

If nobody can introduce you, write to them yourself. Keep it short and plain: a first line about them, one line on what you do, and your question. Most of the rules in how to cold email investors work here too: plain text, no attachments, no links, and a clear ask at the end.

How to ask: help first, the mentor question later

Go in this order:

  1. Ask for help with one problem. One question, and either a short call or a reply by email. Don't ask "Will you be my mentor?" in a first message. It asks a stranger for an open-ended commitment before they know you, and the easy answer is no, or no answer at all.
  2. Make the call easy. Before it, send your one-line description, where you are, and the question. Keep to the time you asked for.
  3. Report back. A week or two later, tell them what you did with their advice and what happened. If you decided to do something different, say so and say why.
  4. Ask again when the next problem comes up. If the first conversation helped, a second question is natural. Keep it just as specific.
  5. Ask the mentor question once the relationship is there. If there's good chemistry and they keep being willing to help, at some point you can ask whether you can consider them your mentor, or something along those lines. By then the question mostly puts a name on what's already happening.

A made-up example: from one question to a mentor

Imagine a founder, Ana, building software that texts small vineyards when frost is likely in the next two days. Everything in this example is invented: Ana, the people, the numbers and the timings. She has never sold anything to farmers. Ten growers are trying her product, they all say it's useful, and none of them has paid.

She finds Marta, who spent years selling irrigation equipment to vineyards and now works in another field. Nobody Ana knows can introduce them, so she writes:

Subject: Selling to small vineyards

Hi Marta,

Your post about why growers don't trust new sensors matched what we keep hearing. We're building software that texts small vineyards when frost is likely in the next two days.

Ten growers are trying it and all say it's useful, but none has paid yet. When you sold to vineyards, what got a grower from "useful" to signing?

Would you have 20 minutes for a call in the next few weeks? A reply by email would help just as much.

Best,
Ana

Marta says yes. On the call, she tells Ana that growers decide before the frost season, not during it, so a trial that runs into spring is too late. Ana moves her offer forward. Three weeks later she writes again: what she changed, that two growers signed, and that one said no and why. Marta replies with the name of a co-op manager worth talking to.

Over the next few months, Ana writes when she hits a new problem: what to charge larger estates, and whether to hire her first salesperson. Each time it's one question. After the fourth call, Marta is asking how things are going before Ana writes. So at the end of the season Ana asks: "You've helped me a lot this year. Would you mind if I thought of you as my mentor?"

How to get the most from a mentor

  • Start with what has changed. Open each conversation with what happened since the last one, then the one or two things you need help with.
  • Treat advice as input. A mentor who only agrees with you isn't helping, and one who disagrees isn't deciding for you. You make the call. When two mentors tell you opposite things, how to get honest feedback on your startup covers what to do.
  • Give something back. Tell them how things turned out. Pass on an introduction or something you've seen in your market when it's useful to them.
  • Have more than one. Different people know different problems. One mentor for sales and another for hiring is normal.

Mistakes that cost you a mentor

  • Asking for introductions to investors on the first call, before they know your work well enough to vouch for it.
  • Disappearing after the call, then coming back only when you need something.
  • Taking an hour when you asked for twenty minutes.
  • Expecting months of set work for free. That's an advisor's job, and advisors are paid.
Join 700+ founders who got personalized advice

Ready to Move Faster?

Get actionable feedback and insights on your challenges and goals. 30 minutes focused on helping you move forward.

No sales pitch. No obligations. Just helpful advice.